Aromatic Bitters Family in Cocktails: The Ultimate Guide for Enhancing Your Mixology Skills

This article comes to you from the team of Alambika, leveraging our years of industry expertise to enrich your knowledge. 

More than just a cocktail store, we are a collective of Montreal-based experts dedicated to the art of mixology and the culture of hospitality. 

Every product mentioned has been personally assessed by us for quality, incorporating advice from leading bartenders and sommeliers, to ensure inclusion in our extensive portfolio. 

By choosing Alambika, you're not only supporting our community but also ensuring access to outstanding products that meet our rigorous standards.

Dive into the world of aromatic bitters with our detailed guide, designed for mixologists and cocktail lovers alike. Discover the best aromatic bitters for whiskey, gin, rum, and more, including Angostura, Peychaud’s, and innovative brands like Ms. Better's. Learn how to pair bitters with spirits to elevate your cocktails, and explore tips for experimenting at home. Perfect your craft and impress with every sip.

The Essence of Aromatic Bitters

The Essence of Aromatic Bitters

At the heart of many a memorable cocktail lies a secret hero: aromatic bitters. These potent concoctions, often housed in small, apothecary-style bottles, pack a punch far beyond their modest volume might suggest. But what exactly are aromatic bitters, and how do they stand apart in the vast sea of cocktail bitters?

Aromatic bitters are a complex blend of herbs, spices, roots, bark, and fruits, meticulously infused into a base of alcohol. The term "aromatic" itself hints at their primary characteristic: a rich, multifaceted aroma that complements their intense flavor profile. Unlike their cousins in the bitters family, which might target specific flavor notes like orange, chocolate, or even lavender, aromatic bitters are celebrated for their depth and complexity, offering a symphony of flavors in just a few dashes.

What truly distinguishes aromatic bitters is their versatility and balance. They are the Swiss Army knife of the bitters world, capable of enhancing a wide array of cocktails without overpowering the primary spirits. This balance comes from their intricate composition, which often includes a blend of botanicals such as cinnamon, clove, anise, and citrus peels, among others. Each ingredient is carefully selected to contribute to the bitters' overall harmony, adding layers of flavor that can transform a simple drink into a sophisticated cocktail.

Moreover, aromatic bitters are not just flavor enhancers; they are also revered for their ability to marry disparate elements within a cocktail, creating a cohesive and balanced drink.

Navigating the Diversity of Aromatic Bitters

While it's true that nearly every bitters brand offers its take on aromatic bitters, not all are created equal. The diversity within this category is vast, with each brand bringing its unique blend of botanicals, spices, and secret ingredients to the table. This variety means that even within the realm of aromatic bitters, there's a spectrum of flavors, aromas, and potential uses in cocktails and culinary creations. Let's explore what sets some of the leading and contemporary aromatic bitters apart and how these differences can influence your choice for specific applications.

Navigating the Diversity of Aromatic Bitters

Angostura Aromatic Bitters

Perhaps the most iconic and widely recognized, Angostura bitters boast a recipe that has remained unchanged since the 1820s. Originating from Trinidad and Tobago, these bitters are known for their balanced blend of herbs, fruits, and spices, with a notable emphasis on gentian, a root that contributes to its distinctive bitterness. Angostura's flavor profile is robust and versatile, making it a staple in classics like the Manhattan and the Old Fashioned.

Peychaud’s Bitters

Hailing from New Orleans, Peychaud's carries a lighter body and a slightly sweeter, more floral profile compared to Angostura, with a distinct anise and cherry note. Its unique characteristics make it the bitters of choice for the Sazerac cocktail, contributing to the drink's complex flavor and signature pink hue.

Regan’s Orange Bitters No. 6

While not a traditional aromatic bitter, Regan's deserves mention for its aromatic qualities that extend beyond the typical citrus realm. It introduces a spicy complexity with hints of cinnamon and clove, making it a fantastic addition to cocktails that benefit from a citrusy yet deep, aromatic profile.

Fee Brothers Old Fashion Aromatic Bitters

Known for their sweeter profile and the inclusion of unique ingredients like cinnamon and nutmeg, Fee Brothers' version is less about the bitterness and more about adding a warm, spiced complexity to cocktails. This makes them particularly suited for drinks where a pronounced spice layer is desired, without overwhelming bitterness.

Scrappy's Aromatic Bitters

Founded in Seattle in 2008, Scrappy's Bitters represents the craft cocktail movement's embrace of artisanal and handcrafted ingredients. Their aromatic bitters are a testament to this philosophy, offering a bold, complex blend of organic herbs and spices. Scrappy's focuses on achieving a balance of traditional bitter flavors with nuanced notes of cardamom, nutmeg, and cinnamon, making it a favorite among bartenders seeking depth and intensity in their creations. Its potent profile is especially well-suited for enriching the flavors of whiskey and rum-based cocktails.

Ms. Better's Bitters

Hailing from Vancouver, Canada, Ms. Better's Bitters is known for its innovative and experimental approach to bitters. Their aromatic variant is no exception, blending a unique array of botanicals that include both traditional and unexpected ingredients, such as black pepper and cacao. What sets Ms. Better's apart is not just their ingredient selection but their commitment to natural processes and high-quality, organic inputs. This results in a versatile and intriguing aromatic bitter that excels in both classic cocktails and avant-garde concoctions, offering a modern twist on the traditional aromatic profile.

Embarking on the aromatic bitters journey opens up a world of flavor possibilities, and while we've highlighted some iconic and intriguing options, it's just the tip of the iceberg. The market is brimming with a diverse array of aromatic bitters, each bringing its unique twist to the classic concept. For those just beginning to explore the vast landscape of bitters, starting with aromatic varieties is a wise choice. Their inherent versatility and ease of pairing make them an excellent foundational tool for both budding and seasoned mixologists. Aromatic bitters seamlessly integrate with a wide range of spirits and mixers, reducing the guesswork and enhancing the enjoyment of cocktail crafting. This accessibility doesn't compromise on depth or complexity; rather, it invites creativity and experimentation, making aromatic bitters a perfect starting point for delving into the art of mixology.

Crafting with Aromatic Bitters

Aromatic bitters are the alchemists' secret to transforming good cocktails into great ones, adding layers of flavor that can elevate the simplest ingredients into a complex and satisfying drink. Understanding how to pair these bitters with different spirits and mixers can unlock a world of taste and aroma, making each sip a journey through the senses. Here, we'll explore some exemplary pairings and offer tips for experimenting with aromatic bitters in home bartending.

Pairing Aromatic Bitters with Spirits

While the world of aromatic bitters offers a rich palette of flavors suitable for enhancing a wide array of cocktails, it's worth noting that these bitters are quite interchangeable in many recipes. This versatility means you can experiment with different bitters in your favorite drinks to discover new taste profiles and nuances. However, if you're at the crossroads of where to begin, a good rule of thumb is to match a bottle of aromatic bitters with your preferred spirit. This approach not only simplifies the selection process but also ensures that the bitters you choose will likely complement the flavors you already enjoy. Whether you're a fan of the smoky notes of whiskey, the botanicals in gin, or the warmth of rum, starting with a spirit-centric pairing can be a delightful way to embark on your aromatic bitters journey.

colorful cocktails

Whiskey : The robust, often smoky flavors of whiskey make it a prime candidate for pairing with aromatic bitters. Angostura, with its rich history and complex blend of herbs and spices, complements whiskey's depth, enhancing its natural flavors without overshadowing them. Try it in a classic Old Fashioned or a Whiskey Sour to add a new dimension to these beloved cocktails.

Gin : Gin's botanical notes are a perfect match for the floral and citrusy undertones of Ms. Better's Bitters. The bitters can highlight gin's herbal qualities without competing with them, making for a harmonious blend. A Gin Martini or a Gin and Tonic with a dash of Ms. Better's Bitters can elevate the drink with minimal effort.

Rum : Rum varies widely in flavor, from light and sweet to dark and complex. Scrappy's Aromatic Bitters, known for their balanced yet pronounced spice profile, can complement both ends of the spectrum. Add them to a Rum Punch or a Mojito to introduce an extra layer of spice that ties the drink together beautifully.

Tequila : The earthy, sometimes smoky qualities of tequila are wonderfully enhanced by Peychaud's Bitters. Their light, sweet, and floral characteristics can soften tequila's sharpness, making for a more rounded drink. A Tequila Sunrise or a Margarita with a few dashes of Peychaud's can offer a refreshing twist on these classics.

Vodka : Vodka's neutral flavor makes it a versatile base for experimenting with various bitters. Fee Brothers Old Fashion Aromatic Bitters, with their sweeter profile and hints of cinnamon and nutmeg, can add a warm, spiced complexity to vodka-based cocktails, such as a Moscow Mule or a Vodka Martini, without overpowering the spirit.

Tips for Experimenting with Aromatic Bitters in Home Bartending

  1. Start Small : Bitters are potent, so begin with just a dash or two to understand their impact on your cocktail.
  2. Mix and Match : Don't be afraid to combine different bitters to create a custom flavor profile. A dash of one type with another can produce surprising and delightful results.
  3. Think Beyond Cocktails : Aromatic bitters can enhance non-alcoholic beverages, too. Add them to sparkling water, tea, or even coffee for a twist.
  4. Use in Cooking : Aromatic bitters can add depth to savory dishes and desserts. Experiment with a few drops in marinades, sauces, or baked goods.
  5. Keep Notes : As you experiment, jot down what works and what doesn’t. This will help you refine your mixology skills and develop your signature drinks.
various cocktails

By exploring the wide range of aromatic bitters available and experimenting with different spirit pairings, you can elevate your home bartending game and delight your palate with every sip.

If you want to learn more about bitters, check out our article Introduction to Bitters

Vesta Michel

The Author: Vesta Michel

Vesta Michel is a cocktail enthusiast and co-owner at Alambika. Drawing from her firsthand experience in the world of glassware, barware, and cocktails, she aims to educate about this complex subject, provide industry insights, and share her love and passion for the art of beverage alchemy and hospitality.

More reading